2006-11-06

Top Five Flaws In Torchwood

In early interviews, series creator Russell T. Davies described Torchwood as The X-Files meets This Life - though he now shies away from the comment, presumably to let the new brand stand apart from its influences.

So... what's gone wrong so far?

5. The most interesting "regular" died in the first episode.
4. Fun-loving Jack Harkness from Doctor Who is traumatised here.
3. Despite the sex and swearing, it still feels like children's television.
2. Torchwood has neat corporate branding for a secret organisation!
1. Jack's car has go-faster lights in the front windscreen.

Torchwood is perfectly fine filler while we wait for the next instalment of real Who but I do hope Mr. Davies isn't spending too much time on ideas for Series Two. At this rate, it'll be time wasted.

10 Comments:

Blogger The Paranoid Mod said...

And Dr. Who's not in it. That has to count as a major flaw...

20:53  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

In short, it's shite?

I hate it. It annoys me to think or talk about it. I'm angry now writing this! Really! ;)

How dare anyone align This Life to Torchwood? This Life was genius TV. These shows should never again be uttered in the same sentence. There'll be trouble!

SEE! You've started me now!

'... presumably to let the new brand stand apart from its influences.'

No, he shies away from it now because he knows that his comment was nonsense and he wants to save himself further embarrassment more like.

I'm going to stop before I pass out. Me poor nerves!

21:36  
Blogger C said...

It sounds like a painful condition to me.

05:10  
Blogger The Paranoid Mod said...

On the bright side, they're making a one-off "This Life" 10yr-on special at the moment.

09:03  
Blogger tenderhooligan said...

They are? I saw them on the cover of the Guardian magazine (or Independent magazine) at the weekend, but I never got around to reading it. A 10-year-on special could be interesting.

Someone told me lately that This Life isn't available on DVD, which surprised me, but a quick search of Amazon proves that incorrect. I might have to purchase.

09:41  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

The most recent episode did have a fight between a Cyberman and a dinosaur. I'd commission that.

09:18  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

...Cyberman and a dinosaur.

I watched it last night on whatever BBC channel it was repeated on. That part really frightened me, I have to say.

And, Marcus, the guy in the suit (I can't remember any of their names) finally got a part, huh! They must have heard us bitchin'!

10:54  
Blogger The Paranoid Mod said...

Yeah, but couldn't they just cut out the attempts at plot and characterisation and cut to the alien gladiators?

Not that I've actually seen it. I just assumed from the amount of hype thrown at it that it would be poor. And spinoffs are always rubbish. Apart from Frasier.

20:15  
Blogger thisismarcus said...

Mod: There's a five-minute version on the website under "highlights". Sounds perfect for you!

Strange Pills: click "This Life" in the body of my article for news about the ten-year reunion.

I should say that there's much I like about Torchwood - beautiful Cardiff, beautiful Gwen, etc. But the stories are so derivative as to be recognisable to fans of the genre.

Do they vet applicants or give any kind of training at Torchwood? In three out of four episodes so far the danger has come from *within* the team (Suzie with a knife, Owen with another knife and Ianto with a robot girlfriend). Jack issues a ban on taking stuff home from the office and two episodes later Gwen does just that. Who appointed an alien head of this alien research team anyway?

I just wish it made more sense. It's hardly adult TV when someone of my reduced mental acuity can pick this many holes in it.

10:00  
Blogger The Paranoid Mod said...

To be fair, you can pick holes in almost all scifi on the telly. I have to say, though, that I've got bored of Russell Davies productions, you know it will look good but where's the beating nerd heart of the plot?

"here's some stuff, joke or two, nice graphics, run around a bit, she's got nice cheekbones, explosion, shouting, the end."

Film 10 and laugh all the way to the bank...

18:05  

Post a Comment

<< Home